Behavioral Questions5 min readPremium

Leading without formal authority

How would you handle leading a team if you didn’t have formal authority watching over you?

Personal leadership isn’t dependent on holding a formal title; it simply requires a desire to inspire others to perform at their best. Mark Murphy, founder of Leadership IQ and author of Hiring for Attitude, describes a food manufacturing company that credits much of their success to the prevalent attitude of personal leadership among their employees. From the machine operators on the shop floor to the CEO, everyone embodies a positive personal leadership attitude. Interviewers want to know how you lead without formal authority, and a STAR method-style story is the clearest way to show it.

How do they define personal leadership? Here’s their criteria:

  • Keeps their word.
  • Steps up and offers assistance when needed.
  • Enjoys taking on new responsibilities and encourages others to do the same.
  • Treats everyone with respect.
  • Maintains a positive attitude that motivates others.

Your organization might have a different definition of personal leadership, and that’s perfectly fine. The key is to know how to interview candidates to determine if they possess the personal leadership qualities that align with your organization’s needs.

Murphy recommends an interview question that works regardless of your specific definition of personal leadership. Understanding it from the interviewer’s side helps you answer it well as a candidate:

Can you describe an instance where you demonstrated personal leadership?

Although this seems like a straightforward question, its simplicity is its strength. Notice that it doesn’t include any leading prompts like “what were the circumstances and how did you respond?” Adding such leads is a common mistake among hiring managers.

This simple, non-leading, open-ended question, asked exactly as it is, effectively reveals a candidate’s genuine perspective on personal leadership for two significant reasons.

First, the question is so basic that it compels the candidate to define “personal leadership” in their own terms. This is beneficial. For example, if someone responds with, “Whenever I tried to lead, I ended up with the tasks no one else wanted and it wasn’t worth it,” it’s a poor answer, but it’s also incredibly informative. It reveals a lot about the person’s attitude towards personal leadership and their definition of it. They’ve equated personal leadership with ‘being stuck with unwanted tasks,’ which is a clear signal not to hire them.

If your organization’s success relies on individuals stepping up and taking personal leadership, regardless of how unpleasant the task, this response is a major red flag indicating that this candidate may not be a good fit.

Individuals who rarely step up and take personal leadership may not have much to share. On the other hand, those who thrive on personal leadership don’t need any prompts; they will effortlessly recount numerous instances where they demonstrated it.

Having a well-crafted interview question is crucial, but knowing how to evaluate the responses is equally important. After all, what’s the point of administering a test—interviewing is indeed a form of testing—if you don’t have a grading key to accurately assess the responses?

An entire chapter of Hiring for Attitude is dedicated to creating and utilizing Answer Guidelines. These guidelines provide real-life examples of both good and bad answers to your organization’s interview questions. Hiring managers who use Answer Guidelines are adept at recognizing high and low performers based on their responses. This equips them to consistently and accurately evaluate candidates’ attitudes towards personal leadership or any other qualities your company values.

Here are real-life examples (both good and bad) of answers to the interview question, “Could you tell me about a time you showed personal leadership?” They come from the Answer Guidelines developed for the food manufacturing company mentioned above.

Here’s an example of a “bad” answer:

“It was impossible to get any control at my last job. I often found myself as the only experienced operator in the group. I could have easily taken control and done things the right way if anyone had cared to listen, but most of those guys were clueless. I would have had to go person-to-person and say ‘here, let me show you how to do that,’ but it was just too much work and I wasn’t being paid to train. That would have been a different story. Bottom line, I just didn’t get the respect I deserved for my skill level.”

If the question had been phrased to steer the candidate toward the one instance where they “successfully assumed a role of personal leadership,” this candidate could have hidden their attitude behind a rehearsed success story. This is why the question, although it may feel awkward initially, is designed to be open-ended.

Now, let’s consider what this client deemed a “good” answer:

“One time, our lead man called out. I stepped in because I was the most senior employee in our department. Initially, I felt nervous, not knowing what to expect, but my attitude and my work history with my team quickly boosted my confidence. I knew that, no matter what, I would have the team’s support, and we would accomplish any goals set before us. Needless to say, we achieved our goals for that day. I learned a new role and have not looked back since. Our team is awesome!”

Why is this considered a good answer? Firstly, it’s very specific; it even explains why the situation arose, providing the opportunity for this person to step into a leadership role. This specificity suggests that the experience is likely genuine. Secondly, the candidate embraced the opportunity positively, despite initial nervousness, and made a real impact. They infused their positive attitude into others, took ownership of the situation, and didn’t seek all the credit but instead praised their awesome team. High performers naturally want to share their successes; it’s just what they do.

Whether you develop Answer Guidelines or use another form of an answer key, understand how high and low performers in your organization respond to the interview question: “Could you tell me about a time you showed personal leadership?” Then, during your next round of interviews, test your candidates by asking this question and listen carefully for the characteristics of high and low performance in their responses.

How to Lead Without Formal Authority as a Software Engineer

If you’re the candidate, the good and bad answers above show what interviewers listen for: a specific situation, ownership without a title, a positive attitude toward extra work, and credit shared with the team. Pick a story where nobody asked you to lead, such as owning an incident, unblocking another team, or driving a cleanup everyone avoided.

“Our frontend build had crept up to 12 minutes, and everyone complained about it, but nobody owned it. I profiled the build, found that we were type-checking the whole repo twice, and proposed moving type-checking to a separate CI step. I wrote a short doc, got buy-in from the two other teams sharing the pipeline, and paired with an engineer from each team to roll it out. Build time dropped to 4 minutes, and one of those engineers now owns build performance for their team.”

This answer works because it names the problem, shows initiative without formal authority, brings other people along, and ends with a measurable result.